TL;DR
-
Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong pulled support for the Senate's CLARITY Act crypto bill just before a key vote.
-
Main issues: bans on stablecoin rewards for holders and tokenized stocks - hits users hard and lets banks dodge competition.
-
Markup delayed, industry divided, but fixes are in talks. No bill beats a bad one, he says.
Stablecoin rewards top the hit list. The draft stops platforms from paying yield on coins just sitting in wallets - think 5% returns on USDC without lifting a finger. Banks can still offer interest on deposits, though. Armstrong calls it banks banning competition.And it's not just that. A de facto ban on tokenized equities kills Coinbase's plans to trade on-chain stocks next year. DeFi rules could hand government eyes on your wallet history - worst expansion since Patriot Act days and it tilts power to the SEC over CFTC.
Coinbase reviewed the 270-page monster dropped Monday night.
By Wednesday, they bailed publicly.
Armstrong posted on X "We'd rather have no bill than a bad bill. Harsh, but the stakes hit their product lines hard.
Banks vs Crypto Clash
Wall Street lobbied hard here. They fear stablecoin yields pulling deposits - folks ditching 0.5% savings accounts for crypto's better rates.Crypto doesn't do fractional reserve lending like banks, so less systemic risk, Armstrong argues.Over 52 million Americans touch crypto daily. If this bill passes as is, it shields banks from real rivalry. Consumers lose choice and yields that beat inflation.Stablecoins hold $150 billion plus. Rewards draw users in, building habits. Strip them, and you hand banks a moat while claiming consumer protection. source
Industry Splits Open
Not everyone's with Armstrong. Ripple's Brad Garlinghouse stays optimistic, pushing markup fixes. Kraken and Digital Chamber back advancing it .Coinbase's move smells like leverage. High-stakes poker to force better terms. But TD Cowen analysts see it derailing the whole thing this session.Bitcoin hit $97k amid the noise markets shrug off D.C. drama. On-chain shows whales stacking up.
What Fixes Look Like
Compromises float around. Rewards okay for active use , transact, stake, liquidity provide. Idle coins means No yield. Aligns with some Dem proposals.Tokenized assets might get carve out if tied to real regs. DeFi surveillance dialed back. But banks dig in on stablecoins.With Trump in office since '25, crypto push has GOP muscle. Congress wants a win. Realistic shot at revised bill by spring, if egos bend.Armstrong bets on re-engagement. "Catastrophic" for users otherwise, he told CNBC. Crypto needs rules - just not ones rigged for incumbents.
This snag shows how fragile these deals are. Banks guard turf, crypto fights for air, lawmakers juggle it all. Users areStuck waiting.
Closing Statement
Armstrong's stand spotlights a raw truth - good rules lift everyone, bad ones pick winners. Push for that better draft. Crypto's too big now for half baked laws
